The Most Highly Ranked SUVs for Practical American Buyers
If you are shopping for an SUV, you have likely come across lists of "best" models from various publications. But what actually makes an SUV highly ranked? For us, it is a combination of crash test scores, predicted reliability, owner satisfaction, fuel economy, and resale value. This guide covers the most highly ranked SUVs across different segments, focusing on what matters for real-world ownership. We have combed through data from Consumer Reports, J.D. Power, IIHS, and NHTSA to bring you models that consistently top the charts and make sense for your wallet.
What Makes a Highly Ranked SUV Stand Out?
A highly ranked SUV does not just excel in one area; it performs well across the board. Safety is non-negotiable: Top Safety Pick+ awards from IIHS and five-star NHTSA ratings separate the leaders from the pack. Reliability matters equally—nobody wants a loaner car every few months. Owner surveys reveal satisfaction scores that reflect real-world livability. Finally, value retention ensures that when you sell or trade in, you get a decent return. Models from Toyota, Honda, Subaru, and Mazda often dominate these high rankings because they balance mechanical longevity with modern features.
Top Highly Ranked Compact SUVs for the Daily Commute
Compact SUVs are the sweet spot for many buyers: manageable size, decent cargo space, and lower fuel costs. Among highly ranked compacts, the Honda CR-V stands out with its excellent reliability ratings, spacious interior, and comfortable ride. The Subaru Forester earns top marks for safety and standard all-wheel drive. The Mazda CX-5 is praised for its engaging driving dynamics and upscale cabin. All three hold their value well and have above-average predicted reliability. For a budget-friendly pick, the Hyundai Tucson offers a long warranty and good fuel economy, though its rankings are slightly behind the Japanese trio.
Highly Ranked Midsize SUVs That Families Love
Midsize SUVs offer more passenger and cargo room for growing families. The Toyota Highlander is a perennial top pick thanks to its unmatched reliability, strong resale value, and available hybrid option. The Kia Telluride and Hyundai Palisade have skyrocketed in rankings due to their spacious third rows, generous features for the price, and impressive crash scores. The Honda Pilot also remains a solid choice with versatile seating and a smooth powertrain. If you need towing capacity, the Mazda CX-9 provides a premium feel and good handling, though cargo space is a bit tight compared to its rivals.
How Highly Ranked SUVs Perform in Resale Value
Resale value is a key metric for any highly ranked SUV. According to Kelley Blue Book, the Subaru Forester, Honda CR-V, Toyota Highlander, and Kia Telluride consistently hold 50-60% of their value after five years. Good examples include the Toyota RAV4, which often retains over 55% of its MSRP. This matters because depreciation is the single biggest cost of ownership for many buyers. Choosing a high-ranking model means you pay less in ownership costs over time, even if the initial price is slightly higher.
Safety and Reliability: The Backbone of Highly Ranked SUVs
Safety ratings from IIHS and NHTSA should be on your checklist. Models like the Subaru Forester and Mazda CX-5 earn Top Safety Pick+ awards year after year. Reliability data from Consumer Reports shows that Toyota, Honda, and Mazda produce the most dependable SUVs, with fewer reported problems in the first three years. Avoid models with frequent recalls or known transmission issues—even if they have good marketing. A highly ranked SUV is one you can trust for years without unexpected repair bills.
Affordable Highly Ranked SUVs for Budget-Conscious Buyers
You do not have to spend top dollar to own a highly ranked SUV. Models like the Honda CR-V, Mazda CX-5, and Toyota RAV4 offer excellent reliability and safety without the luxury price tag. Used examples that are three to five years old can often be found for under $25,000, and they still carry the same high ratings as new versions. When shopping for a pre-owned highly ranked SUV, check the vehicle history report, confirm that all safety recalls have been addressed, and look for models with a certified pre-owned (CPO) warranty. This combination of initial value and long-term dependability makes these SUVs a smart financial move. Many owners report low maintenance costs and strong resale value even after several years of ownership. For example, the 2019-2021 Toyota RAV4 hybrid offers excellent fuel economy and remains one of the most reliable highly ranked SUVs on the used lot. Similarly, the Subaru Forester consistently earns top safety scores and has a loyal following among outdoor enthusiasts. Always compare insurance rates for any used SUV, as some models have lower premiums than others. A certified pre-owned highly ranked SUV from a dealership often comes with extended warranty coverage, giving you extra peace of mind. Ultimately, choosing a highly ranked SUV that fits your budget does not mean sacrificing quality.
Final Advice for Choosing a Highly Ranked SUV
The question isn't whether a highly ranked SUV is good—it's whether it fits your life. Test drive at least three of the top contenders. Consider your climate, family size, and budget for fuel and maintenance. If you plan to keep the SUV for more than five years, prioritize reliability and resale value from the list above. If you lease, focus on the models with the best incentives and residual values. Regardless of your choice, stick with consistently highly ranked models to avoid regret. Don't buy the headline; buy the long-term fit.